The new guidance, which supersedes the original version. Summary of the eeoc guidance regarding the use of criminal. Fifth circuit says eeoc cannot use 2012 criminal background. Equal employment opportunity commission eeoc guidance regarding employers use of. Missouri pacific railroad 1975 decision, which identified three factors employers should take into consideration when determining whether a criminal history check is job related and consistent. New eeoc guidance on criminal records kegler brown hill. The enforcement guidance explains how the eeoc analyzes the job related and consistent with business necessity standard for criminal record exclusions, and provides hypothetical examples interpreting the standard. Equal employment opportunity commission eeoc recently issued new enforcement guidance with respect to an employers consideration ofarrest and conviction records in employment decisions.
The equal employment opportunity commission has approved, by a 41 vote, a revised enforcement guidance on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964. Eeocs criminal background check guidance enjoined by. The eeoc does not have the authority to prohibit employers from obtaining or using arrest or conviction records. By a 41 vote, the eeoc clarified that a criminal background check is not unlawful. Eeoc issues new enforcement guidance on use of arrest and. An estimated one in four americans of working age have some kind of criminal record. Enforcement guidance on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964, as amended, 42 u. Eeoc issues new guidance on criminal history in employment decisions. Eeoc issues guidance on criminal background checks cga law firm. Employer use of arrest and conviction records in maryland nolo. Yet, the eeoc still recommends that employers not ask about all convictions on job applications. Jan 16, 2018 a criminal record does not automatically disqualify a candidate from employment. A unique online criminal recordeeoc assessment process crimapollo is an online application that allows you to select the job attributes of a positione. The eeoc periodically issues enforcement guidance regarding various provisions of the law.
Client alert eeoc guidance on employer use of arrest and. Eeoc advisory guidance offers insight on the use of arrest and conviction records. On april 25, the eeoc issued, effective immediately, updated enforcement guidance regarding the use of arrest and conviction records in making employment decisions. The eeoc also issued a questionandanswer document about the new enforcement guidance.
Oct 25, 2011 the eeoc staff attorney explained that, because the criminal justice system requires the highest degree of proof for a conviction i. The guidance consolidates and supersedes the commissions 1987 and 1990 policy statements on this issue as well as. That guidance, which takes effect immediately, is a compilation of the past policy documents and prior court decisions regarding the eeocs position that employers reliance on arrest. Berrien said in a statement, the new guidance clarifies and updates the eeocs longstanding policy concerning the use of arrest and conviction records in employment, which will assist job seekers, employees, employers and many other agency stakeholders. Eeoc new guidance on arrest and conviction records. Eeoc propounds guidance on use of arrest and conviction. Eeoc updates guidance on use of arrest, conviction records. Analysis of the new eeoc enforcement guidance on the use. Employment criminal background check and eeoc compliance. Aug 15, 2019 on april 25, 2012, the eeoc approved its guidance consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964 as part of its efforts to eliminate unlawful discrimination in screening, hiring, or retention.
Employer use of arrest and conviction records in maryland. The eeoc is a member of the federal interagency reentry council, a cabinetlevel interagency group convened to examine all aspects of reentry of individuals with a criminal history. Eeoc updates guidance on employer use of arrest and. Eeoc guidance on arrest and conviction records in employment. Commission on civil rights heard from stakeholders on dec. Eeoc guidance on use of criminal history in employment decisions. The equal employment opportunity commission eeoc has issued an updated enforcement guidance on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii. Eeoc issues guidance on criminal background checks hr.
Whether the individual is bonded under a federal, state, or local bonding program. Newly updated enforcement guidance from the equal employment opportunity commission eeoc addresses criminal background checksspecifically, the use of arrest and conviction records to make. Equal employment opportunity commission eeoc issued an enforcement guidance document titled enforcement guidance on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964, as amended, 42 u. Eeoc issues updated criminal record guidance that highlights.
Eliminate policies or practices that exclude people from employment based on any criminal record. Client alert eeoc guidance on employer use of arrest. The eeoc guidance for employers explains that under title vii laws, employers cannot deny employment based on arrests or criminal convictions unless the offense is jobrela. Equal employment opportunity commission eeoc issued a revised guidance on the application of title vii to criminal records on april 25, 2012. Definition of employment criminal background checks being eeoc compliant. Eeoc guidance places limits on employers use of conviction records by katy rand last month the equal employment opportunity commission eeoc issued enforcement guidance regarding when and how an employer may rely upon criminal background information without running afoul of. Equal employment opportunity commission eeoc enforces title vii of the civil rights act of 1964 title vii which prohibits employment discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex including pregnancy, or national origin. Rather, the guidance identifies when and how an employers use of arrest and conviction records may violate title vii. Equal employment opportunity commission eeoc has issued an enforcement guidance for title vii of the civil rights act of 1964 that updates its policies regarding criminal conviction discrimination.
Under the new guidance, the eeoc presumes that employer use of criminal history. Questions and answers about the eeocs enforcement guidance. Equal employment opportunity commission eeoc today issued an updated enforcement guidance on employer use of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964, as amended title vii. The eeoc does not prohibit criminal conviction consideration in hiring. On april 25, the eeoc issued updated guidance on the use of arrest and conviction records in hiring and employment decisions. Program, annual survey of jails, and annual parole survey as presented. The eeoc guidance for employers explains that under title vii laws, employers cannot deny employment based on arrests or criminal convictions unless the offense is jobrelated. In our first post, we provided a todo list based on the april 25, 2012 enforcement guidance eg issued by the eeoc on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii. New eeoc enforcement guidance on arrests and convictions in. According to the eeoc, there are two ways in which an employers use of criminal history information may violate title vii.
The eeoc further recommends that employers meet with candidates and give them the opportunity to explain or refute the findings of the background check. In december 2012, the commission issued a strategic enforcement plan that included targeting background checks as a barrier to employment. Nov 21, 2019 in april of 2012, the eeoc issued enforcement guidance on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964 that recommended if employers ask about criminal convictions that the inquiries be limited to convictions for which exclusion would be jobrelated for the. Equal employment opportunity commission eeoc guidance regarding employers use of criminal background. Commission updates guidance on employer use of arrest and conviction records. In april of 2012, the eeoc issued enforcement guidance on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964 that recommended if employers ask about criminal convictions that the inquiries be limited to convictions for which exclusion would be jobrelated for the. Consistent with its enforcement guidance on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii, the eeoc alleged that freemans criminal background checks on. One eeoc recommendation is that employers should not use policies with blanket exclusions based on criminal records, and that applications should no longer include requests for criminal history. The eeoc guidance states that excluding applicants andor employees for arrests alone is not considered by the eeoc to be jobrelated and consistent with business necessity. For the past few years, the equal employment opportunity commission eeoc has publicly discussed the need to update its enforcement guidance concerning the use of arrest and conviction records in hiring and employment. The implication, of course, is that if employers do not embrace and implement the best practices they will. In 2012, the eeoc updated its guidelines on employers use of arrest or conviction records in hiring decisions. By contrast, a criminal conviction makes it more likely that the individual did in fact engage in the criminal conduct at issue. In fact, the equal employment opportunity commission eeoc has sued companies for doing this, claiming they violated title vii of the civil rights act of 1964.
Federal court slams the door on eeocs criminal background. Sloan the equal employment opportunity commission eeoc recently published new guidelines for how employers should 1 handle inquiries into arrest and criminal conviction records of applicants and employees, and b make employment and hiring. May 01, 2012 eeoc issues guidance on employers use of criminal records in hiring may 1, 2012 by jeffrey s. Analysis of the new eeoc enforcement guidance on the use of. The new guidance reflects the eeocs enforcement position, which it likely will pursue.
But, the commission explained its view that the use of criminal histories can be discriminatory in impact on minorities and will result in liability for employers if they. Eeoc advisory guidance offers insight on the use of arrest. Texas wins challenge to eeoc guidance on criminal background. The 2012 eeoc guidance discouraged employers from excluding all job seekers with criminal records and recommended that, in addition to assessing each criminal record hit for jobrelatedness and. The eeoc simply seeks to ensure that such information is not used in a discriminatory way. Guidance on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in. Littler attorney demystifies new eeoc criminal history guidance. Eeoc issues guidance on use of criminal records in hiring. These laws are enforced by the equal employment opportunity. Further, the eeoc imposed additional restrictions on the use of arrest. Eeoc guidance on employer use of criminal records in hiring.
Eeoc guidance places limits on employers use of conviction. Over the last few years, the equal employment opportunity commission eeoc has been cracking the whip on employers over the use of criminal background checks during hiring. New eeoc enforcement guidance on arrests and convictions. Eeoc guidance on employer use of criminal records in. However, an assessment of the conduct underlying the arrest may be used to exclude an applicant andor employee as long as the exclusion is not based on the arrest alone. With many employers conducting background checks and inquiring about conviction records, employers should take note of the new guidance for possible changes in their policies and practices. New eeoc enforcement guidance on arrests and convictions in employment decisions posted on 05032012 at 03. Further, the guidance seeks to provide employers with an understanding of how the eeoc applies the three factor test set forth by the 11th circuit in green v. In order to exclude an applicant based on a criminal conviction, the eeoc staff attorney stated, the criminal conduct should be recent enough and sufficiently jobrelated to be predictive of performance in the position sought, given. Eeoc guidance on arrest or records staff management smx.
If an employer decides to ask about criminal records, the eeoc recommends that the employer limit its. Eeoc guidance on use of criminal history in employment. Equal employment opportunity commissions guidance documents regarding the use of arrest or conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964, as amended, 42 u. A unique online criminal record eeoc assessment process crimapollo is an online application that allows you to select the job attributes of a positione. The equal employment opportunity commission eeoc has issued guidance explaining how employers can screen out applicants whose criminal records pose an unreasonable risk without engaging in discrimination. Using conviction records as a screening tool, retail industry update, june 2012. Eeoc issues new enforcement guidance on the use of. Eeoc files claims with two employers for use of criminal. Eeoc updates enforcement guidance on arrestconviction records. Eeoc issues guidance on employers use of criminal records in hiring may 1, 2012 by jeffrey s. The eeocs guidance sets forth a list of best practices for employers regarding the use of criminal arrest and conviction information. Eeoc pier 1 discrimination charge employment screening. Eeoc issues guidance on criminal background checks cga.
Apr 26, 2012 that guidance, which takes effect immediately, is a compilation of the past policy documents and prior court decisions regarding the eeocs position that employers reliance on arrest and conviction records may have a negative impact on individuals because of race or national origin. Before disqualifying an individual with a criminal record from employment, the commission emphasizes, employers should engage. May 03, 2012 the guidance, which updates and consolidates existing eeoc guidance documents on the subject that have previously been left unchanged since 1990, focuses on employment discrimination based on race and national origin. Today, the equal employment opportunity commission eeoc issued an updated enforcement guidance document on employer use of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under federal law title vii. May 14, 2012 of course, there are always exceptions according to the eeocs guidanceand certain industries are subject to federal mandates requiring organizations to disqualify applicants with a specific conviction in a certain specified number of recent years i. Fisher phillips eeoc loses again on criminalbackground checks. In deciding whether a particular offense should be. Brochure arrest and conviction records in employment.
Of course, there are always exceptions according to the eeocs guidanceand certain industries are subject to federal mandates requiring organizations to disqualify applicants with a specific conviction in a certain specified number of recent years i. On april 25, the eeoc approved enforcement guidance on an employers use of criminal background checks in making hiring decisions. Enforcement guidance on the consideration of arrest and eeoc. The issue of using arrest records to exclude candidates is an old issue previously decided. Apr 26, 2012 the eeoc does not prohibit criminal conviction consideration in hiring. Highlights of eeocs new criminal record guidance april 26, 2012 in bipartisan fashion by a vote of 4 to 1, the u. Consolidating and superseding previous eeoc guidance on criminal background checks, the guidance discourages blanket exclusions of individuals who have been convicted of crimes and encourages the use of individualized assessments of whether an employers. Arrest and conviction records in employment best practices. The commission today voted 41 to approve the guidance document. Last year, we wrote about the eeocs thennew guidance on the use of criminalbackground checks in hiring decisions. The guidance discusses the differences between arrest and conviction. How to conduct individualized assessments in background checks. The us equal employment opportunity commission eeoc has issued new enforcement guidance on employers use of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions.
Consistent with its enforcement guidance on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii, the eeoc alleged that freemans criminal background checks on all job applicants violated title vii by disparately impacting africanamerican job seekers. On april 25, 2012, the eeoc approved its guidance consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964 as part of its efforts to eliminate unlawful discrimination in screening, hiring, or retention. The guidance, which updates and consolidates existing eeoc guidance documents on the subject that have previously been left unchanged since 1990, focuses on employment discrimination based on race and national origin. The eeocs 2012 criminal records guidance act prepared for iertf meeting. Shrm seeks clarification on eeocs criminal background. Eeoc issues new guidance on the use of criminal background. This new federal ruling gave little weight to the eeocs prior statements on the subject of using background checks to screen employees in a nondiscriminatory manner. Equal employment opportunity commission eeoc or commission issued its enforcement guidance on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964, as amended, 42 u. Equal employment opportunity commissions guidance documents regarding the use of arrest or conviction records. By a 41 vote, the equal employment opportunity commission eeoc on april 25, 2012, approved a new guidance on criminal background checks. The purpose of this enforcement guidance is to consolidate and update the u. Equal employment opportunity commission eeoc enforces title vii of the civil rights act of 1964 title vii which prohibits employment discrimination based on race.
Equal employment opportunity commissions guidance documents. On april 25, 2012, the eeoc issued updated enforcement guidance on employer use of arrest and conviction records. The eeoc s guidance sets forth a list of best practices for employers regarding the use of criminal arrest and conviction information. The guidance distinguishes between an arrest and conviction. The equal employment opportunity commission eeoc recently released a new guidance in reaction to a federal appeals case on the topic of using arrest or conviction records to screen employees. In april of 2012, the eeoc issued enforcement guidance on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964 that recommended if employers ask about criminal convictions that the inquiries be limited to convictions for which exclusion would be jobrelated for the position in question and consistent with business necessity. Eeoc updates guidance on use of arrest, conviction records in. The equal employment opportunity commission eeoc recently issued updated guidance on the subject of employer use of applicants criminal records in hiring decisions.
In the enforcement guidance web page, the eeoc reminded us about the green v. Shrm seeks clarification on eeocs criminal background check. What you should know about the eeoc and arrest and. Eeoc guidance places limits on employers use of conviction records by katy rand last month the equal employment opportunity commission eeoc issued enforcement guidance regarding when and how an employer may rely upon criminal background information without running afoul of title vii. Eeoc cannot use 2012 criminal background history guidance. The fact that an individual was arrested does not establish that criminal conduct has occurred, and an exclusion based on an arrest, in and of itself, is not job related and not consistent with business necessity as described above. Apr 26, 2012 one eeoc recommendation is that employers should not use policies with blanket exclusions based on criminal records, and that applications should no longer include requests for criminal history. Equal employment opportunity commission eeoc has issued an enforcement guidance for title vii of the civil rights act of 1964 that updates its. That includes discrimination based on race, color, national origin, sex, or religion. In july 2011, the equal employment opportunity commission eeoc held its latest meeting on the topic of protections for job applicants with arrest and conviction records under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964. Eeoc issues new guidance on the use of criminal history in employment. However, the guidance sets forth a number of recommended best practices.
What you should know about the eeoc and arrest and conviction. The guidance updates, consolidates, and supersedes the commissions 1987 and 1990 policy statements on this issue, as well as the. In deciding whether a particular offense should be disqualifying, employers must consider. On april 25, 2012, the commission, in a 41 bipartisan vote, issued its enforcement guidance on the consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964, as amended, 42 u.
May 08, 2012 newly updated enforcement guidance from the equal employment opportunity commission eeoc addresses criminal background checksspecifically, the use of arrest and conviction records to make. Enforcement guidance on consideration of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964. The guidance discusses employer practices that the eeoc considers permissible and impermissible based on its interpretation of title vii of the. By carl crosby lehmann and abigail crouse, gray plant mooty law firm, minneapolis. The eeoc voted 41 to approve the guidance document. The agencys enforcement efforts were kicked off in 2012 when it published its controversial enforcement guidance on use of arrest and conviction records in employment. The implication, of course, is that if employers do not embrace and implement the best practices they will have enforcement problems with the eeoc. District court for the northern district of maryland dismissed a race discrimination lawsuit filed by the eeoc. In december 2012, the commission issued a strategic enforcement plan that included targeting background checks as a barrier to employment of minorities.
861 424 1413 1013 513 1105 1183 1181 540 1538 845 1099 946 1071 482 1255 975 1086 386 1475 830 130 1000 563 1291 300 1065 480 347 673 1216 647 1151 850 589 1377 105 1380 1484 111 1217 428